Chercán, a Chilean five-piece, is back about a year after the fantastic self-titled debut. Canto de Silicio (Eng.: Silicon Song) sees them refine their sound. Heavy prog with ample jazz flourishes is their bread and butter, but they also dip their toes into a bit of electronica and world music on this release. Those farther-out touches are most prominent on the multiple short interludes on this album, but they help to break things up.
Band: Asceta | Album:The Fool Leading the Blind | Genre: Progressive rock, Avant-prog | Bandcamp
The new album from this Chilean instrumental ensemble features some daring and exciting music. Chamber music plays a major part in Asceta’s sound, with the band frequently channeling early RIO acts. The 21-minute title track is often tense. Reed instruments, tinkling piano, and wobbly, wonky rhythms constantly keep the listener on unsure footing. I also really like the 10-minute closing song, which is relatively guitar-forward by this band’s standards. The three songs in between are good compositions, as well, but they feel less necessary. Maybe they could have been shortened, or maybe one could have been left out altogether. Despite that, The Fool Leading the Blind is an engaging and creative record.
Score: 80/100
Band: Dreadnought | Album:Wars of Spirit // Wards of Light | Genre: Progressive metal, Post-metal | Bandcamp
Dreadnought‘s newest album sees some rare churn in the band’s lineup. Longtime keyboardist and co-vocalist Lauren Vieira has left the band, with guitarist/flutist/lead vocalist Kelly Schilling taking over key duties. Coming four years after The Endless–an album I initially gave a very positive review to, but which hasn’t quite held up over the ensuing years–WoS//WoL features a pretty daring evolution in their sound.
Gothic metal–most notably Tiamat–is a huge influence on this record. The synth tones are both lush and airy, but Dreadnought still manages to retain a lot of their powerful doom metal riffage. The occasional folk and jazz flourish shows up here and there for some nice contrast. Dreadnought was never shy about including minimal, ethereal moments on their records, and this one is no exception. If anything, that ethereal quality is more pervasive than ever. The band also dips their toes into electronic music on “Aeonwar”, to mixed results. And the closing “The Twilight Protectorate” features some wonderful, victorious-sounding sci-fi synth tones. I really respect Dreadnought for switching things up on this album and evolving their sound. The end result is pretty solid, overall, though there are some mild stumbles here and there.
Chilean post-rock sextet Hesse Kassel are back with their second full-length release. Last year’s La Brea had a ton of really solid music on it, but on repeated listens, its biggest hindrance is its crushing length. Eight songs with an average runtime of nearly ten minutes can make for an exhausting experience, even in the hands of very skilled songwriters and musicians. The songs on Morir Saltando (Eng.: To Die Jumping) retain all the strengths of those on their debut, but they are more focused, giving them more impact.
Band: END! Begin | Album:The END! | Genre: Progressive folk | Bandcamp
This collection of four instrumental pieces is a solid follow-up to END! Begin’s fantastic debut LP. The overall mood is a bit more energetic and less torporous here, and I really appreciate getting to see this other side of the band. “Cherry Blossoms” in particular draws a lot from rock music, which is a very exciting blend.
Score: 78/100
Band: Mellow Beast | Album:Grimble, The Worm | Genre: Psychedelic rock | Bandcamp
Mellow Beast’s latest record sees him expand upon the musical universe he has established. The story of this record takes place right after Reactor, his 2023 release. Throughlines are obvious in the music, and there are even connections to earlier releases. The mood is spacy and often-hypnotic while also imbuing some Gong-ish fun and whimsy.
Welcome to The Elite Extremophile’s Top Prog Albums of 2025! As usual, this is a two-part list of 50 total entries. Part two is here.
As a reminder, the music on this list spans December 2024 through November 2025. Music from December 2025 will be on the 2026 list. I’m sure there is plenty of good music I missed, but when it comes to the reviewing, this is a one-man operation. (My proofreaders/editors, Kelci and Dan, have been very helpful, as always.) There are also certain trends and styles I simply don’t like very much.
2025 was a fantastic year for progressive rock and related genres. I was spoiled for choice with this list, and this may be the overall-strongest batch of recommendations I’ve given to date.
Artist: Gianni Carlin | Album:In nessun luogo | Genre: Progressive rock | Bandcamp
In nessun luogo features a mildly-lo-fi sound, but it works well. Flute is always prominent, providing some great, breathy contrast to the fat and rubbery bass that underpins much of the music. The songwriting is overall solid, though the 21-minute album opener is a bit unfocused at moments. There are some surprisingly catchy passages mixed in, and with the occasional dash of jazz and blues, it makes for a well-balanced record.
The debut record from this Chilean ensemble features intricately structured epics that unfold slowly. Delicate moments contrast heavier passages. Post-punk and art rock influences abound, and there is also clearly a deep debt to Windmill scene bands like black midi and Squid. While I overall like this record, it does have one glaring flaw, and that it is way too damn long. 78 minutes across eight songs leaves a lot of fat to trim, even when taking into account the fact that this is a post-rock record. This band is at their best during their heavier moments, like on “A. Latur”.
This instrumental release heavily incorporates jazz and classical elements into its compositions. Reed and wind instruments can be found among the many slinking themes present here. Things swell and retreat fluidly, and there are a lot of great tonal and textural choices. While I enjoy it overall, this isn’t the most distinctive record. It’s solid, jazzy instrumental prog, if that’s what you’re looking for.
Score: 74/100
Band: An Abstract Illusion | Album:The Sleeping City | Genre: Progressive metal | Bandcamp
An Abstract Illusion’s latest record is a noticeable step down from their last release, 2022’s excellent Woe. The Sleeping City isn’t a bad record, by any means, but it’s unimpressive. The biggest problem for me on this record is the production. Everything is very clean and clear in a way that robs the band’s death metal of its impact. The clean parts of this record also come off as overly glossy and sterile, with many of the synth tones sounding out of place. There are still good ideas in the compositions, but the sound of the album itself is lacking.
Chercán is a Chilean quintet that plays a lush, complex, and engaging variety of progressive rock. Things are densely layered and smartly composed, and the band incorporates jazz and sounds from their homeland. Everything about this record really impresses me.
Band: Arcane Atlas | Album:Constellation Plus | Genre: Progressive rock, Art rock | Bandcamp
Arcane Atlas plays a relatively light and relaxing variety of prog. Expansive atmospheres and lush textures have a calming effect, and there are some really enchanting passages here. ‘90s Rush and ‘90s Yes are the most obvious influences to my ear. This album’s instrumental moments are its best. This duo does a great job at establishing a mood and toying around with drama. Not everything here is a winner (“Sample”, in particular, was a tough listen for me), but this band’s occasional veers into soft rock are forgivable in the end. If you’re looking for something intelligent but soothing, Constellation Plus is a good choice.
Score: 76/100
Band: Bent Knee | Album:Twenty Pills Without Water | Genre: Art rock | Bandcamp
This is a welcome return to form for Bent Knee after their unimpressive last outing. Smart pop hooks are mixed in amidst creative and surprising arrangements. The textures are lush, and the vocals are strong, as usual. Parts of this record can veer into less-distinctive sorta-art-poppy-type stuff every now and then, but overall, Bent Knee does a great job at weaving together accessible and inventive elements.